Privates vs Regular Class Training /// By: Vincent Inoncillo
Jiu-Jitsu is an art that can be practiced throughout a lifetime. It doesn't matter when the journey begins just as long as it starts. As mentioned in previous entries, practitioners come in all shapes, sizes and backgrounds. Some rely on athleticism, some rely on technique, while others use a combination of both. It's common for some to grasp the concepts of technique and movement quicker while it takes a little more time and effort for others to get on the same page. We were all made differently and each of us comprehend and progress through our jiu-jitsu journey at different rates.
Due to the fact that every practitioner learns jiu-jitsu differently, private lessons and regular class training can be beneficial to improving one's techniques, understanding, and overall game. Regular classes are more of a general learning experience where the instructor teaches techniques to the whole class. A training partner is essential in this learning setting. Private lessons offer more attention to the student from the instructor. These two avenues of learning offer similar and contrasting benefits to the student.
Let's think of training in a regular class as learning in a classroom setting in school. The teacher has a curriculum of subjects, or in this case techniques, to teach their students and is available for assistance to clarify any details during the the class. Training in a regular class can consist of warm ups, learning and drilling techniques with a partner and live sparring. A huge benefit of a class setting is training and sparring with different partners with different belts and body types who utilize various sets of their own preferred techniques.
On the flip side are private lessons. Private lessons are taught by an instructor and can be comparable to tutoring sessions in school. During these sessions a student can receive a more personalized approach to learning jiu-jitsu. It's a more individualized learning process and they get the teacher's full attention. They can go over the little details they're missing in their techniques during class and can ask any additional questions they may have. A plus to private lessons are that the instructor can give their recommendations on techniques and sequences the student can employ with their current skill set.
A couple of instructors gave their insights on regular classes and private lessons. Sonny Nohara, a seasoned competitor and black belt instructor from Las Vegas, says, "If someone can afford private lessons on a regular basis, I think it is very beneficial because you can really focus on the details and intricacies to positions while getting one on one attention for an hour. That's for lower belts when you're early in your jiu-jitsu journey. I personally only took 2 privates in my life and they were both when I already had my black belt. I think you should take advantage of taking a private from someone you try to emulate or has a similar body type to you if you have the chance. I also think people learn at different rates so some people can get really good without taking any privates and some people will benefit more from it." Tahomar "TG" Gil, a brown belt kids instructor offers his point of view saying, "They each address different aspects of the game. And one can't substitute the other. But if you have to chose one, definitely go with regular class. It will be a longer road. But only privates wouldn't provide the diversity in sparring you need (technique levels, styles, sizes, body types, etc)."
Professor Nohara makes a good point saying that one should take advantage early in their journey by taking private lessons when and if they can. He also agrees that everyone learns differently and at different rates so if you learn a little quicker than others taking regular classes and skipping out on the privates might not be so bad. Professor TG highlights the beneficial aspects of both private lessons and regular classes as well. The extra instruction never hurts and also allows you to focus more on what your game can turn into. The beauty of regular class is training with different partners who have different body types and play their jiu-jitsu differently. It causes you to react or act according to how your partner plays. No matter which road you take definitely do the regular classes for the variety of training partners, but also try to venture out and take advantage of learning one-on-one from your instructor or from someone else. Your jiu-jitsu is what you make it, so make it work for you.