Live Training vs Fighting
A couple weeks ago, I came across John Danaher’s Instagram post about training vs fighting. He says:
“Training vs fighting: A fundamental tenant of fighting is to avoid your opponent’s strengths whilst imposing your own. Interestingly, in training I recommend that you often do the exact opposite. In fighting and competition (shiai) THE OBJECT IS VICTORY. In training, the object is SKILL DEVELOPMENT – DO NOT CONFUSE THEM. As such, one of the best ways to train is to identify the strengths of your various partners, AND REGULARLY EXPOSE YOURSELF TO THOSE STRENGTHS. This is a splendid way to build skills, particularly defensive skills. Here, Georges St-Pierre works with Nicky Ryan. Of course Mr St-Pierre could easily take Mr Ryan down and play a game of disengagement, but he recognizes that such a tactic would offer very little skill development. Instead, he opts to maximize training value by going against Mr Ryan’s formidable leg locking and guard passing skills from bottom position. When students make a clear distinction between training and competition and the different priorities of the two, rapid skill acquisition is common. Failure to make the distinction usually leads to students who have a skill set of favorite moves which does not grow over time. Training sessions tend to become very repetitive and dull. KEEP IN MIND THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN TRAINING AND COMPETITION AND YOU WILL BE REWARDED WITH GROWTH OVER TIME, no matter how frustrating it may seem in the short term. Be mindful of one of the central paradoxes of jiu jitsu training – THE MORE VULNERABLE YOU MAKE YOURSELF IN THE TRAINING ROOM, THE LESS VULNERABLE YOU WILL BE IN COMPETITION.”
Photo credit: John Danaher (IG: @danaherjohn)
It’s almost as if Mr. Danaher read my mind (and explained it much better). Why try to compete with and kill your training partners when you can do that in competition when it really counts? Are people too consumed by their ego in live training to work on (or expose) their own weaknesses?
Let’s keep it real people. Nobody likes one trick ponies. If you’re good at a few key moves – good for you. But that doesn’t mean it’s going to work for you every single time on every single person. Even more importantly, how are you ever going to evolve? And also, shouldn't you save your aggression for opponents rather than your training partners? After all, you can't get better without training partners.
The bottom line is that your improvement in BJJ is based on how willing you are to throw your ego out the window and be able to be the nail AND keep showing up despite feeling beat down by the hammer every day. You will at least get 1% better each time and your progression will greatly increase over time the more you focus on your skill development rather than who you can “beat” in training that day.
Also, remember that drillers make killers. If you are not working on specific training and are just going into live training or “sparring” without a game plan (except to just be the dominant player), you’re doing it all wrong. Be vulnerable, work on your weaknesses, and remember that in the gym, it’s all about skill development NOT victory - that's what competitions are for.